Boring Whales Through AI And Committees: New Territory.

The reported 20 minute conversation between whales and humans-via-AI is interesting and is probably one of the best uses of AI that I can think of (rather than writing gibberish for the Internet).

Of course, this fires up the imagination – effectively, it’s a first contact scenario, which can include all manner of mistakes that could have repercussions. It’s not hard to think of them saying funny things. Imagine chatting with an old, grizzled whale who effectively says, “Get off my lawn!” or a young whale that is going through puberty and is only chatting to impress a female whale somewhere around the planet.

There’s so much that we might get wrong.

Imagine a group of Marine Biologists of the most serious sort chatting with a pod of whales for the first time.

Marine Biologists: *summoning call*

Pod of whales shows up and starts making noise.

Marine Biologists chattering to each other, “What are they saying? They’re talking a lot!” The resident AI expert – Bob, of course – says, “Give it time, give it time, the AI is catching up. There’s a few of them making whale sounds!”

Finally, the AI spits out some text: “What do you want?”

The Marine Biologists start chattering among each other and trying to decide what to send back.

The whales leave since nothing else is happening, making sounds that carry across the oceans around the world…

The Marine Biologists gape at one another as they stare at Bob, who in turn is staring at the screen waiting for the translation:

“There’s someone pretending to be one of us but they don’t know what they want. Ignore them. Fake news!”

One of the Marine Biologists sighs and says, “Well, we screwed that up…”

“In the Future, the World Will Make Sense”

I was taught at a young age that the world made sense but when I grew up I found that it made as much sense as we had made sense of it.

I suppose as a child being made comfortable with the idea that the world made perfect sense made me easier to deal with.

Some people never seem to get past the need for the world to make sense. The very idea that we don’t understand the world is too much for most of us. I wake up every day wondering about something I don’t yet have the answer to – at least one thing. Every morning when I wake up there’s an implicit acknowledgement that the world doesn’t make sense and it’s fun learning new things.

Some people don’t see the world that way. Some people fear new things. Some people prefer the comfort of belief that they do understand everything. These people trouble me. In fact, they trouble other people who believe different things. No, I’m not talking about religion. I’m talking about politics, which effectively is another religion. If I point out weaknesses in a candidate, these people default to thinking I must be on the ‘other side’. That’s almost never true.

People pick their own narratives, and there is nothing wrong with that. The only side anyone should pick in a democracy, in my humble opinion, is their own. You’re supposed to vote your interests in a democracy.

In this past election, some people voted for the building that they sought comfort in. Some voted for the wrecking ball because that building bothered them for some reason, though there are no plans to build anything in it’s place. This election is a reset on a lot of things in that regard, and the next one could be better, or it could be worse, and everyone will have an opinion on that and some will be told their opinion by people with impossible hair on their favorite news channel.

All you need to be a pundit is to get people to believe that they are less intelligent than you are, and it’s alarming how easy it is. Cherry picking facts, painting with a broad brush, and hair that defies the body it’s on.

Part of getting past that is understanding our own biases. Someone in an urban setting sees the world one way, someone in a suburban setting sees it another way, and someone in a rural setting sees it in yet another way. Each one grows up in a different culture and while we like to think they have the same values, there are small differences because of the different cultures.

If you can step outside of your biases long enough, the world is not the same. Yet political pundits like you right there where you are. The systems, many of which seem broken, are designed to keep you where you are – that’s the role of bureaucracy, to stall change. And the people who profit from it all? There you are.

Does it make them bad people? Nope. Being ‘bad people’, too, has a lot to do with culture. Famously, the Greeks called anyone who wasn’t Greek a barbarian, and here we are still waiting for the barbarians.

…Now what’s going to happen to us without barbarians?

Those people were a kind of solution.

Constantine P. Cavafy

For lack of actual barbarians, maybe the political pundits should be who we call barbarians.

That would make more sense to me.

Democracy Is About People, Stupid.

what the hell?

There’s little that hasn’t been written or said about the U.S. Presidential Election. When asked about it, I have been saying that there were two bad candidates and one of them had to win.

This pisses off people who are emotionally attached to one of the two. I’m ok with that. One represented individual oligarchy, one represented corporate oligarchy, and if you can’t tell which is which then maybe you’re part of the problem.

The people whose candidate won have been pretty happy. The people whose candidate lost have been trying to figure out why. It’s gotten so bad that LinkedIn has become a toxic waste dump of curated perspectives on… well, that, the Democratic party, and all the other stuff that probably shouldn’t be posted by people who want to hire someone or be hired by someone. It’s become further polarized because of it.

And that’s what helped get the result. People are viewing ‘those people’, whoever they are, as all sorts of negative things without understanding things.

Jon Stewart and Sarah Smarsh had a conversation about it… and the content probably should have been spoken about decades ago. It’s almost an hour long, but some people really need to watch this.

Identity, class… things that I hear progressive democrats talk about a lot and yet they somehow miss the boat consistently on that.

America is a big and diverse place, and it’s bigger and more diverse than most perspectives I’ve seen expressed. I have friends across the spectrum. I don’t have to agree with them, but I do have to understand their perspectives.

When looking at politics, people look at the narratives provided and if it fits their personal experience and identity better than the other narrative, they choose that one. Rationality might be discussion before voting, but voting is emotional for a lot of people.

It’s about people. Stereotyping them in a negative way ain’t gonna make things better. Understand the people who a democracy is supposed to represent, don’t depend on data analytics.

Go outside and listen. Respect people enough not to treat them like spreadsheet.

New Host: Hostinger. Same RealityFragments

So… it’s been quiet around here lately, though my mind has not been. One of the things I was waiting for was jumping to a new host. Goodbye, Automattic! Goodbye WordPress.com! The tiers of managed hosting were not priced to my liking, the AI scraping thing that I really didn’t like the default setting of, etc.

Freedom comes at a cost, so I’ll have to be more about managing the site than I used to be – but it ain’t really that hard for me. Wrestling Drupal 11 would be much more of a headache at this point, but I almost did switch…

So the site is on Hostinger.com now. Well, it, as well as 2 others as well as a few unannounced projects.

I went into more technical reasoning for changing hosts at KnowProSE.com.

Web hosting is a thing. I have a technical mind, as you will see if you visit KnowProSE.com, but I have more than a technical mind, as you see here on RealityFragments.com. We are more than just one mind.

That’s a bit of a hint about one of the projects I’m working on which is a hint about one of the projects I’m working on – mainly writing.

Other than that, quite a lot has happened since last I wrote here. Despite everything, the world has managed to continue rotating.

Back to writing!